Homemade Egg Nog

Homemade Egg Nog

A delicate, creamy homemade egg nog that's easy to make and tastes incredible! The flavors of freshly-grated nutmeg, vanilla, whole eggs, real cream, and maple syrup blend into this incredible egg nog!

Yield: 

about 12 cups

Ingredients: 

9 large eggs
1 cup real maple syrup
1/4 teaspoon salt
6 cups milk, divided
2 tablespoons vanilla extract
3/4 teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg
1/8 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1 cup heavy cream

For serving:

3/4 cup whipped cream
Freshly grated nutmeg

Instructions: 

1. In a heavy 4 or 6-quart pan, briskly whisk together the eggs, maple syrup, and salt, until well-mixed. Whisk in 3 cups of the milk.

2. Heat over medium heat, whisking constantly, until mixture reaches 160-165 degrees F (use a candy or meat thermometer to monitor temperature).* It takes me about 10-15 minutes, and I do whisk near-constantly for this step! You will see a little steam rising from the pan, just as the egg nog reaches 160-165 degrees.

3. Remove from heat. Whisk in the vanilla, nutmeg, and cinnamon. Whisk in the remaining 3 cups of milk.

4. Cover pan and chill well (a few hours) before serving. Don't put a hot pan in your refrigerator though! If the weather is cold, I set the covered pan outside to cool, and then refrigerate. Otherwise, let cool to room temperature and refrigerate.

5. Whip the 1 cup of heavy cream until foamy, about half-way to "whipped cream". Stir into the chilled egg nog mixture (it will want to float, so stir as much as needed to mix most of it in).

6. To serve, ladle chilled egg nog into glasses, top with a tablespoon of whipped cream, and sprinkle with freshly-grated nutmeg. Enjoy!

This egg nog can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 3 days.

Homemade egg nog

Homemade egg nog

Additional Notes: 

*I usually turn off the burner when the thermometer says about 160, and by the time I've removed the pan from the heat, it's getting up to 165 or slightly higher. Eggs boil at 180 degrees, so you want to stay below that at all costs or your egg nog will be chunky, no matter how much you whisk it, both during and after heating.

Finished egg nog temperature

Original recipe inspiration: Erica at Cooking For Seven.

Note that my version is less sweet, slightly less cream, and the addition of cinnamon. I also had difficulty with the cooking instruction "until mixture thickens and coats the back of a spoon". When I waited for thickening and anything close to "coating", it was already 180 degrees and turning chunky.

Joshua has found the same issues with homemade custard-based ice cream recipes that say to cook until it coats the back of a spoon. Some mixtures might do that just fine (depending on the amount of eggs, thickener, etc.) but others do not. It's best to just watch the temperature and avoid over-cooking the eggs. Even whisking the whole time will not take care of the lumps if the mixture ends up too hot.

Preparation Time: 

15 minutes + chill time

Cooking Time: 

about 15 minutes

Tammy's Review: 

We love, love, LOVE this creamy homemade egg nog!!

This homemade egg nog is amazing. I know I've said in the past that I am not an egg nog fan, because I think it just tastes like uncooked pumpkin pie filling. But this recipe has completely changed my mind!

I've made this homemade egg nog several times over the past month, and everyone who has tried it is amazed by the creaminess and delicious flavor!

I do recommend using a thermometer when making this egg nog. A candy thermometer or meat thermometer should work fine; you just need to get the milk and egg mixture heated up to about 160-165 degrees. Eggs boil at 180 degrees, so you want to stay below that at all costs or your egg nog will be chunky, no matter how much you whisk it, both during and after heating.

Despite needing to accurately gauge the temperature when heating, this egg nog really is an easy recipe and will have your family or friends raving over it!

Read my blog post about this egg nog recipe here.

Homemade egg nog

Comments

I can hardly wait to make this for my kids! I hadn't really thought about it in years, but...

When I was in high school (a long, long time ago), I had to have my jaw wired shut after a procedure. I met with the dietician before leaving the hospital. She recommended that I put food in the blender, add milk, water or juice to thin it out and drink whatever the family was eating. It didn't work. The result tasted horrible. Fibers left in the food got stuck in my teeth...

And, my dad found an old recipe for egg nog. He made batch after batch! I lived on it for an entire summer. Well, that and V-8, and cream of chicken soup that my mom added a jar of chicken baby food to for extra nutrition. (Oh, and that one time I made an ice cream sandwich into a milkshake).

I can almost taste the deliciousness!

Rating: 
5

I love egg nog...and this is by far the best egg nog I've ever tasted. Not as sweet as store bought and an eggless/pudding mix one we've tried before, and I really like that. The more subtle sweetness brings out all the other flavors in a really delicious combination! And doesn't feel so sickeningly sweet or unhealthy, either. Definitely a keeper; we'll be making it again!

Rating: 
5

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

User login

Subscribe for free recipes, menu plans, and kitchen tips!