I was looking for a recipe without shortening and this one did the trick. I had no problems at all. I had just thrown out another supposedly foolproof recipe that would not hold together at all. I replaced the egg with Ener-G egg replacer because we can't use eggs. It seemed to do fine. I have a pie setting in the fridge right now and we will taste it tomorrow at dinner. The other two will be used for a pot pie or maybe an apple pie. I might try mixing in the food processor next time. Good job.